June 25th
Some Days You're the Pigeon; Some Days You're the Statue
1 Peter 2:11-17
There is an old saying that maybe some of you here have heard. It goes something like this: “To succeed in life, we must accept the fact that some days we are the pigeon, and some days we are the statue.”
You know what I mean, right? There are those times when we are flying high. Our friends affirm some profound theological insight we share at a Bible study. If we pastors believe our own press, it seems that our sermons are touching almost everyone in our congregations—at least that is what folks are telling us as they shake our hands on Sunday mornings. Our employers praise our work to no end. If we have partners, they seem to worship the ground we walk on. If we are single, everyone wants to date us. It seems that whatever we touch turns to gold. Oh, yeah! Life is good!
Then there are those other times when we are the statues. We try to get a new and creative program off the ground at work, and SPLAT! The pigeon named “Status Quo” drops his “gift” on us. We pastors work hard to make our sermons educational, relevant, and entertaining, and SPLAT! Both the red and blue pigeons of partisan politics splatter us with “helpful corrections” as they leave the church. When we share our views at Bible study, people give us this look that says, “What planet are you from?” If we have partners, it seems we can’t even go to the bathroom in a way that satisfies them. If we are single, it feels like our phone hasn’t rung in months! It seems that everything we touch turns to, well, something other than gold. Life stinks.
Yep! Some days we’re the pigeons, and some days we’re the statues.
Our passage in 1 Peter this morning may be seen as a bit like a lesson in “pigeon and statue” living for Christians—only on a far more serious level than my examples. After all, as far as I know, none of us here have experienced the same level of persecution due to our faith as was faced by some of the earliest members of the Church. But then again, persecution does come in many different disguises. Amen?
This passage is most likely part of a letter that was written to groups of exiles or resident aliens in different cities that were part of the Roman Empire. It is important to note that these folks were not members of the dominant cultures in the areas in which they lived—in other words, they were in the minority---and as Christians, they faced possible persecution from a variety of sources.
Christian wives could face abusive treatment from non-believing husbands. Non-believing family members could make life unbearable for Christian family members. Government-sanctioned mistreatment by other non-believing members of the community at large was always a possibility. There were possible economic consequences for being “out” as a Christian, as well. So, at first glance, this passage may seem like more of a “statue” passage than anything else. In other words, “Yeah, life may stink; but as Christians, this is how you are to behave.”
But here’s a thought: What happens when you are no longer the exile? Do the rules change? You see, I think if we were all honest with ourselves, we would admit that, while we have different genders, races, sexual orientations, and gender identities represented here today, as Christians we are no longer the exiles—at least not in our churches, communities, and the United States at large. So, what happens when the minority becomes the majority?
Well, if the information we have from Church history is reliable, Christians didn’t get off to such a great start. Popes ex-communicating everyone who disagreed with them—including each other at one point in history; the burning of so-called “heretics;” the Crusades; the Inquisitions; the 30 Years’ War; the burning of alleged “witches;” the forced removal of Native Americans from their lands; slavery. I am sure some of you Church history buffs could name more of Christianity’s more “pigeon” moments—moments where some of our ancestors in the faith dumped a lot of “stuff” on various “exiles” and “resident aliens”—all in the name of God.
Now some of you are probably thinking, “But that was then, and this is now. We don’t do that stuff anymore! So, what’s your point, preacher?” My point here is that there is still a lot of “dumping” going on today—whether we care to admit it, or not.
For example, some folks seem to be trying to protect marriage from what it is supposed to encourage—loving, stable, committed relationships. Racial minorities and women still face discrimination in employment—both inside the church and out. Immigrants who want to be legal residents of the United States face a government system that tends to work against them rather than for them.
And guess who is responsible for shaping a lot of these institutions and policies? Surprise! Many of the folks who are responsible for writing and enacting the policies that shape our society today identify as Christians! And some of these folks actually invoke the name of God as justification for some of these oppressive policies!
So, what do we do about this situation? Is there even anything we can do about this situation? The good news is I believe there is something we can do, and I believe we can find at least one possible course of action in our passage from 1 Peter.
Much of 1 Peter is full of instructions for how Christians are to conduct themselves. So, what I am proposing this morning is that it does not matter whether we are “exiles” or “Gentiles,” whether we are in the minority or in the majority,—whether we are the pigeons or the statues---if we call ourselves Christians, that identity requires us to embrace the practices of appropriate love and respect for all people and human institutions. Sounds like a nice idea, right? But, what does that look like?
At the most basic level of community interaction, we are called to do our best to work within the guidelines of our established institutions. Note I did not say that we have to like these guidelines. We may not particularly care for our elected officials, or the laws they pass. We may not care for our employers and their hiring and promotion practices. We may not even particularly care for our denominational and local church leadership as well as the laws they enforce. But as strange as it sounds, at first glance, this passage seems to tells us, “Oh, well. Too bad, so sad. Today is your day to be the statue. Pray for pigeons with bad aim.”
But is there more behind this passage? I think so. You see, while we are called to accept the authority of all human institutions, and to respect all people, as servants of God, we are also free. Fortunately for us, we are free to question what we see as unfair government laws. What we are not free to do is commit acts of terrorism against our government institutions. We are free to respectfully contest the questionable ethics of the leaders of human institutions, as well. What we are not free to do is slander and physically attack these people.
We are free to question our denominational and local church leadership, as well. What we are not free to do is unfairly attack them and unjustly malign the character and integrity of that leadership. We are free to protest what we see as unjust treatment of various groups of people, animals, and the environment. What we are not free to do is use violence and unjust treatment of others to make our points.
Maybe we could all take a lesson from the civil rights movement here. It may help us to remember that the civil rights movement made some of its biggest strides through the use of non-violent protest. So, is it possible that by respectfully, yet consistently challenging the unfair practices of various societal structures, we can begin to silence the ignorance surrounding issues like immigration policy, poverty, racism, sexism, and homophobia? Is it possible that our examples of positive Christian social action can actually cause folks to eventually glorify God by truly respecting the rights and dignity of every human being?
You see folks, to me, the question isn’t whether we are the statue or the pigeon. To be perfectly blunt, there are probably days when we feel like both. Amen? The question for us is, “If we call ourselves Christian, how do we respond to the challenges of life?”
Maybe in the end, the best we can do is to be in awe of God’s unending love for, and patience with, us—God’s imperfect, but good creations—to honor God by loving one another, and respecting all of God’s creation—including those institutions and people we don’t always like.
Can we do it? Sure we can! For it is through Jesus Christ that we claim our identities as Christians, and it is through that same Jesus Christ that we can do all things.
Maybe even get along, eventually. Amen?
God bless you, and amen.


